Most strategies that fail were perfectly reasonable on paper. The problem was never the slide deck. It was something quieter that nobody named.
Strategies don’t fail in a thousand ways. Strip it down and you land on seven: not seeing, not choosing, not being able, not acting, not understanding, not fitting and not believing. Those are the Seven Cardinal Sins of Strategy: Ignorance, Indecision, Incompetence, Inertia, Confusion, Incongruence and Doubt. They are the leader’s first, and the team’s second. The OGSM is the cure for all seven: one page that leaves none of them anywhere to hide.
Below you’ll find each sin with what it means, what it looks like in practice, the leader’s version, the one question that exposes it, and the cure. If you’d rather find out which ones are yours straight away, take the free Seven Sins diagnostic — 21 statements, about five minutes, no sign-up.
What are the Seven Cardinal Sins of Strategy?
They are the seven ways a reasonable strategy quietly stops working: not seeing, not choosing, not being able, not acting, not understanding, not fitting and not believing.
| The sin | In a word | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Ignorance | Not seeing | Deciding from a picture of the market that is out of date |
| Indecision | Not choosing | Five reasonable answers, and nothing is stopped |
| Incompetence | Not being able | The strategy asks for skills, people, capacity or money you don’t have yet |
| Inertia | Not acting | Agreed, pinned up — and not followed through |
| Confusion | Not understanding | People outside the leadership team can’t say what you’re trying to do |
| Incongruence | Not fitting | Pay, budgets and scoreboards still serve the old strategy |
| Doubt | Not believing | Someone understands the strategy and quietly works against it |
The word “sin” is deliberate. Like the old list, you commit these with your eyes half-open — not out of oversight, but out of comfort. Nobody in a leadership team sets out to ignore the market or to leave a plan pinned to the wall untouched. It happens because the alternative — looking hard, choosing, cutting, confronting — is uncomfortable. None of the seven is a flaw of character. Each names what is missing between a strategy and its result. And once a sin has a name, it is much harder to commit without noticing.
Notice the pattern. The five “In-” sins sit in the system: what you see, what you choose, what you can do, what you act on and what you reward. Confusion and Doubt sit in people’s heads. And every one of them starts at the top. That’s why each sin below comes with a leader’s version: the seven sins are the leader’s first, and the team’s second.
The sins appear first in The Strategy Lie, a business fable coming soon in print, where a mentor named Daniel uses them to help Andy, the new CEO of Florian’s Fastener Solutions, work out why his leadership team can’t agree on what the strategy is. I’ll use Florian’s as the running example below.
1. Ignorance: are you deciding from a picture of the market that’s out of date?
Ignorance is not seeing — deciding from a picture of the market that is out of date, or not wanting to see that the market has moved on.
What it looks like: plans built on last year’s numbers and “what our customers have always wanted”. A competitor’s new offer discovered through a lost deal rather than through analysis. Florian’s had been losing share to a lower-priced competitor for two years before anyone in the leadership team put the numbers side by side. And Ignorance doesn’t stop once the plan is written: it comes back the moment you stop looking.
The leader’s version: you stopped visiting customers, or left the report unopened.
Ask yourself: when did we last test our picture of the market against fresh facts — not experience?
The cure: a SWOT with rules — facts only, three per box — and then keep looking. Gather the key figures (revenue, margin, growth, customer concentration) before anyone writes an Objective. How to do a SWOT right walks through it. Ignorance comes first in the list for a reason: every other choice inherits it.
2. Indecision: does your leadership team have one answer or five?
Indecision is not choosing — five leaders give five reasonable answers to “what is our strategy?”, and nothing is stopped.
What it looks like: ask five leaders separately what the strategy is and you get five sensible, sincere and different answers. At Florian’s, one director wanted to defend core customers on price, another to cut lead times, a third to move into higher-margin segments. None of them was wrong. Together they meant the company had five people working hard in five directions. The tell-tale sign in the budget round: every priority survives.
The leader’s version: you let them stand, because choosing would disappoint someone.
Ask yourself: what have we explicitly decided not to do?
The cure: one Objective, a few Strategies, and a written “we will not”. How to write a great objective covers the first step, and the complete OGSM guide covers the rest.
3. Incompetence: does your strategy ask for capabilities you don’t have yet?
Incompetence is not being able — the strategy asks for skills, people, capacity or money the company does not have yet.
What it looks like: a digital strategy in a business where nobody has built one. A growth plan that needs a second shift nobody has budgeted for. Capable, committed people missing deadlines because the work is genuinely new to them. It isn’t a character flaw. It’s a gap — but a strategy you can’t execute is just a wish, however right it is.
The leader’s version: you heard “we can’t do that yet” as resistance.
Ask yourself: which skills, people, capacity or money does this plan need that we don’t have today?
The cure: name the gap, price it, and make closing it a Measure with an owner and a date — not a footnote. The complete guide to OGSM Measures shows how.
4. Inertia: is your plan agreed, pinned up — and not moving?
Inertia is not acting — the strategy is agreed and pinned up, but not followed through, starting with the leader.
What it looks like: no reviews, nothing stopped, and the work slides back to its old shape. Twenty initiatives running at once, so a little gets done on all of them and enough on none. Inertia is the one sin that always returns. Count on it.
The leader’s version: you launched the strategy and moved on.
Ask yourself: what did we stop doing to make room for this plan?
The cure: the leader chairs a monthly review of the page, and you stop something for everything you start. How to run an OGSM review meeting gives you the agenda, and the most common OGSM mistakes lists the traps that feed Inertia.
5. Confusion: could anyone in your business repeat the strategy?
Confusion is not understanding — people outside the leadership team cannot say what the company is trying to do.
What it looks like: a 40-slide deck that was presented once and never opened again. On the shop floor, the strategy is “grow” — or nothing at all. At Florian’s it was the production supervisor who put it best: it didn’t matter what the leadership team decided, because no one on the floor would know what they were trying to do anyway.
The leader’s version: you sent the page and did not say it yourself.
Ask yourself: could someone who joined three weeks ago say what we’re trying to do?
The cure: the Objective as one sentence anyone can repeat — said in person, and said again. A strategy no one can repeat isn’t being executed; it’s being guessed at. 12 creative ways to communicate your strategy has practical formats.
6. Incongruence: do your pay, budgets and scoreboards fit your strategy?
Incongruence is not fitting — the strategy does not fit the company and its activities, or the company does not fit the strategy.
What it looks like: the strategy says premium, but the sales team is still paid to win on discount. The budget still funds last year’s priorities. The scoreboard in the canteen still counts the old numbers, and decisions still go to the people who made them under the old plan. Nobody refuses the strategy. The system around it simply serves the old one.
The leader’s version: you never reread the pay plan and budget you inherited.
Ask yourself: if an outsider looked only at our pay plan, budget and scoreboards, which strategy would they guess we have?
The cure: pay for, count and praise what is on the page. If a bonus, a budget line or a KPI rewards something your OGSM doesn’t ask for, change it — or accept that it, not the page, is your real strategy.
7. Doubt: is someone quietly working against your strategy?
Doubt is not believing — someone understands the strategy perfectly well and quietly works against it.
What it looks like: nods in the meeting, quiet resistance after it. A key owner who agrees out loud and never quite moves. Concerns voiced in the corridor rather than in the room. Unlike Confusion, this isn’t a communication gap: the person knows exactly what the strategy is. They just don’t believe in it.
The leader’s version: you wavered where the team could see it, or kept a leader who did.
Ask yourself: who has to carry this strategy — and do they actually believe in it?
The cure: an honest conversation, early — and every Measure owned by someone who believes in it. You cannot communicate your way out of Doubt. How to get your team to follow the strategy goes deeper.
How do you find out which sins your business is committing?
Run a short, honest self-assessment before you plan anything — and, if you can, have several leaders do it separately and compare.
The free Seven Sins diagnostic asks 21 short questions, three per sin, about your business as it is today. You get a score for each sin, ranked from highest risk to lowest, and the cure for your top three. Nothing is stored; your answers stay in your browser.
One tip from experience: the most revealing result is not your own score, but the difference between yours and your colleagues’. If five leaders take the diagnostic and come back with five different top sins, that is Indecision showing itself — and it is the best possible agenda for your next strategy session.
To keep the sins in view afterwards, download the one-pager: all seven sins on a single A4 page. Pin it next to your OGSM. When the old habits return three months in — and they will — don’t reread the strategy. Reread this, find the sin you’ve slipped into, and climb out.
How does OGSM cure the Seven Sins?
The OGSM is the cure for all seven: one page that leaves none of them anywhere to hide.
- Ignorance: the page starts from facts, not opinions — a disciplined SWOT before the Objective.
- Indecision: one Objective and a few Strategies leave no room for five answers; the “we will not” makes the choice visible.
- Incompetence: capability gaps become Measures with owners and dates.
- Inertia: a monthly review of the page, chaired by the leader, shows what is moving and what isn’t.
- Confusion: one page and one sentence are something people can actually repeat.
- Incongruence: Goals and Measures tell you what to pay for, count and praise.
- Doubt: every Measure has a named owner, so a missing believer shows up early.
Building the page is the easy part. A realistic first OGSM takes a focused day — how long does it take to create an OGSM? breaks it down — but several of the sins only strike after it is written, so keeping it alive is a discipline you keep for the whole year.
If you would like the diagnosis and the build facilitated, the OGSM Strategy Builder runs a Seven Sins check as Phase 0 in Claude, then walks you through every phase of your OGSM. It won’t decide for you. It makes you choose.
Frequently asked questions
Why are they called “sins”?
Because, like the original seven, they are committed with eyes half-open — not out of oversight, but out of comfort. Each one avoids something uncomfortable: looking hard at the facts, choosing, admitting a gap, stopping something, saying it yourself, changing the pay plan or having a difficult conversation.
Why does each sin start with the leader?
Because the team takes its cue from the top. If the leader stops looking, avoids a choice, launches and moves on, or keeps an old pay plan, the team will do the same. The seven sins are the leader’s first, and the team’s second.
Which sin is the most common?
In my experience Indecision and Inertia show up most often, usually together: a strategy that stops nothing produces too many initiatives, and too many initiatives produce no movement. Most businesses recognise three or four of the seven.
Can a strategy be committing several sins at once?
Yes, and they feed each other. Ignorance produces a strategy that doesn’t fit (Incongruence); Confusion makes Doubt harder to spot; Incompetence quietly turns into Inertia. Start with the highest-scoring sin, not all seven at once.
How often should we check for the Seven Sins?
Before you build or refresh your strategy, and then once a quarter. Ignorance, Inertia and Incongruence in particular creep back in between reviews, so a quick re-check at your quarterly OGSM review is worth the ten minutes.
Strategies rarely fail because the people behind them aren’t capable. They fail because one of seven quiet sins goes unnamed. Name yours — take the diagnostic — and you already know where to start.
Rock on.







